THE NEW OLD WORLD OF AI


Part 2: AI and Capitalism’s Moving Contradiction


Karl Marx would not be surprised by the arrival of Artificial Intelligence – he kind of predicted it. And if he’s right, AI will not be a solution to capitalism’s problems – quite the opposite.

Whether one is for or against AI doesn’t matter. It’s here, and will stay here and continue to expand for better and, for the foreseeable future, especially for worse. It is the logical outcome of the expansion of knowledge within the narrow confines of what serves the interests of capital and of the increasing importance of knowledge (of information) in the capitalist production process. AI not only shows the progress of automation but also promises its expansion to levels that until now were imagined only in science fiction. It will continue to expand knowledge further but within the same confines: its direction will be determined by what it can do for the profits and power of capital. And yet, what it will do for profit in reality, might be the opposite of what the managers of capital are dreaming of.

Technology is not a neutral tool. Not in general and certainly not in the case of AI. The forms it takes, the content it is fed and the tasks it is given, the purposes for which it is used: all are conditioned by capitalism. AI is shaped by capitalism and in turn helps to shape us as subjects of capital.

So it should come to no surprise that some of the most prominent applications of AI so far are in the fields of surveillance, repression and warfare (cyberwar, drone and missile guidance etc.) It is not because of AI per se, but because of the social order we live in that one of its main tasks today is to perfect the means of oppression and destruction.

It is difficult to imagine what AI would look like in a revolutionary post-capitalist world.

A human community focused on its collective wellbeing could not take AI as it has been developed by capitalism and just use it differently. The tool will have to be rebuilt (to what extent is hard to know today). But it will not be thrown away. Science and technology operate within the confines of capitalism but all the knowledge they contain isn’t capitalist in itself and the technology they develop for their narrow aims may have characteristics that allow for an entirely different use. That could be the case for AI. In a post-capitalist world, it could be a tool used to make scores of human activities much easier and more interesting. It could eliminate boring tasks, it is already a fantastic research tool that could become available to all; medicine and other sectors essential for our collective wellbeing could make giant leaps, climate change could finally by addressed in a meaningful way, production methods could be improved to such extent that the possibility of abundance is within our immediate reach…

Am I dreaming? Yes, but like John Lennon, I’m not the only one. Even some capitalists sense the possibility. The financial advisors Citrini Research argued earlier this year in a much talked about essay that AI is eliminating the very root of scarcity. “For the entirety of modern economic history, human intelligence has been the scarce input. Capital was abundant (or at least, replicable). Natural resources were finite but substitutable.” The only thing that was really scarce, that could not be replicated at scale, was human intelligence. But “Machine intelligence is now a competent and rapidly improving substitute for human intelligence across a growing range of tasks.” With no scarcity in the input, there should be no scarcity in the output. The problem is, “every institution in our economy, from the labor market to the mortgage market to the tax code, was designed for a world in which that assumption [of scarcity] held.”

That is true. A capitalist world without scarcity would be a world of overproduction, a world of crisis and collapse. So Citrini fears that what we can expect of the AI revolution in the coming years is “more economic pandemic than economic panacea.”

A more optimistic view is that of the world’s first trillionaire Elon Musk, who calls AI a demon (see part 1) yet confidently predicts that it will open the gates to paradise. AI will do everything, nobody will have to work, unless they want to, as a kind of hobby. Everybody will receive a universal HIGH income. Jon Stewart of the satirical Daily Show sarcastically observed that Musk had become a socialist. The prophet didn’t give any details on how this would work but others have formulated proposals on how it could be financed by taxing the fabulous profits the AI-based economy would generate. The left would applaud.

All such ideas are based on the assumption that more productivity growth means more profit growth means more wealth that can be shared. But this is not how capitalism works.

The moving contradiction

Capitalism’s big problem does not come from outside, it’s capitalism itself, Marx observed. “Capital itself is the moving contradiction, [in] that it presses to reduce labour time to a minimum, while it posits labour time, on the other side, as sole measure and source of wealth.”i

The first side of the contradiction is easy to see: capitalism presses to reduce labour time to a minimum because the capitalist makes more profit when he uses less labor time per product than the competition, and the capitalist who does not adopt the same labor time saving technology goes bankrupt. So capitalism is compelled to continue this pressure endlessly, thereby revolutionizing its own system, making it ever more technology-centered.

The other side of the contradiction “it posits labour time as sole measure and source of wealth” is less obvious. It may be obvious that what the capitalists accumulate is not just concrete possessions, nor is it simply money. They accumulate these things, but they do it for the value that is contained in them.

That value is hidden. You can’t see or smell it. Abstract labor time became value, the measure of wealth, because that’s how the market works: by comparing, through countless exchanges, the average labor time that the various commodities required for their production.

That ancient ground rule still rules today. More than ever, since capitalism has transformed the whole world in a market and made everything a commodity, something to buy or sell. To buy and sell, to exchange commodities, their exchange value must be comparable. To be comparable, they must have something in common. The only thing they have in common, besides having a use-value, is that it takes a certain quantity of labor time to make them (this includes the past labor time that made the machines etc, as well as living labor), So by comparing the amount of average social labor time the production of commodities require, they can be exchanged at equal value.

Since nobody wants to sell more value in exchange for less value, or to buy less value in exchange for more, that is the rule, the “law of value”. It goes without saying that this rule is often violated. Prices deviate from value because of shifts in supply and demand, because of the interventions of the state (tariffs, taxes, financial policies etc) and more. They deviate as well when technological progress gives one or a few capitalist entities control over the market for their products. That is a constant aim sought by many but reached only by few, and only temporary. It is what drives the IT sector and AI in particular. Because with monopolistic or duopolistic or oligopolistic market control, like Nvidia has, or ASML, or Anthropic and OpenAI together, you can indeed exchange less value for more. But if there is open competition the escape from the rule cannot last. Tendentially, the market restores the law of value.ii The hope of these companies is that by the time they lose their dominant market position they will be able to come up with new products over which they will again have monopolistic control, and they invest many billions towards that purpose, praying that, when they get there, the market will be there as well.

Everything that is used to produce commodities – resources, infrastructure, technology, labor power – are commodities themselves. Their value is determined like that of all commodities: by the abstract labor time that went into their making. So the value of the commodities they produce together over a cycle is the sum of their own spent values, the total abstract labor time that these commodities were made with. And yet it is more than that. Value grows in production because labor power is a commodity unlike all others. Like all others, its value is determined by the abstract labor time needed to make it, in this case, the labor time needed to produce the goods and services which in a given society, at a given point in time, are needed for the maintenance and restoration of labor power.iii That labor time is the value of the wage. It might require, for instance, an aggregate 4 hours of labor time to make what a day’s wage buys. But if it’s an 8 hour workday, there are 4 additional hours of labor time added to the value of the production at no cost to the owner of capital. That is the surplus value, the sole source of wealth, in the Marx quote above, since all other components of the production process only pass on their own value to the produced commodities. They don’t add new labor time, new value, to them. Only living labor does.

Because value remains value in its money form, keeping its purchasing power, its access to all other commodities, it can be accumulated. The law of value, over time, overturned the very purpose of production: in all previous societies, even those ruled by privileged classes, the purpose of production was to make things that were wanted and needed (in the first place by the ruling classes of course). In capitalist society the goal of production, the reason why it is undertaken (or not) is profit. Yes, it must meet needs as well, there must be a demand for its use-value. But rather than being the social goal, satisfying needs and wants has become the means towards the real social goal of production: accumulating value.

But the fact that value can be accumulated doesn’t imply that it is stable. Obviously, most commodities that remain unsold lose their value quickly. Machines can lose part or all of their value when cheaper or better versions enter the market. Money seems an unperishable commodity but it too can only keep its value if it remains part of the accumulation process. Like other commodities must metamorph into money to keep their value, money, to keep its value, must morph back into productive commodities that will continue the accumulation, valorize the invested capital, because of the living labor they contain.

Capitalism’s constant pressure to reduce labour time to a minimum has changed the world at an amazing pace. The capitalist technology which resulted from it and of which AI is the provisional highpoint, has been a spectacular success story, if you look at it from the point of view of productivity. Production and markets have grown tremendously, the law of value now rules the whole world.

Reducing the necessary labor time means that commodities become cheaper, which widens the markets. The goods that workers buy with their wages are cheaper as well, require less labor time, a smaller part of their work day, so that they work longer for the capitalist for free. Furthermore the capitalist technology is aimed at intensifying the labor process, at squeezing more relative surplus value out of the workers.

The scale-enhancement made it possible to expand production as if there existed no limit to the market. But the limit was imposed by the value form itself since there is no market where there is no more value to exchange with, where the conditions for value creation are destroyed because the threshold for capital formation can’t be reached anymore. And capitalism’s constant pressure to reduce the value of the working class’s wages and at the same time to increase the scale of production was bound to generate overcapacity, periodic crises of overproduction (how these were ‘overcome’, through crisis and war, falls outside the scope of this article).

Capitalism has conquered all lands, all sectors, all markets and it has created many new ones, but it can never overcome the inner limit to its market which is baked into its system based on exploitation and deprivation of the majority of the population. The more it reduces the relative weight of living labor in the production process, the more it restricts new value creation on a global scale, and therefore the growth of its global market as well. The more technology-centered production becomes, the greater the amount of value that needs to be invested in past labor (that has passed on its value into the objects it created) in order to set in motion the same amount of living labor from which surplus value is extracted. The more developed capital already is, the more past labor (infrastructure) is needed to incorporate enough living labor to extract surplus value from. Thus, “The self-realization of capital becomes more difficult to the extent that it has already been realized.”iv

So the threshold for new capital formation keeps rising. Today, it’s higher than ever. To start a chip-factory now, for instance, would set you back more than two billion USD and the cost of a data center will rise to 100 billion USD in the near future according to NVIDIA’s now disgraced leader Jensen Huang. The rise of this threshold implies an ever greater dependency on credit and an ever greater role of the equity markets. It reinforces the tendency towards increasing concentration of capital. The AI sector is a glaring example. Its entire trillion dollar infrastructure is owned by only a handful of companies. One CEO, Elon Musk, controls half of all satellites, including those the Ukrainian military depends on, as was recently shown. The main cost of the AI infrastructure are the data centers which are its factories where all the computing occurs. Economist Paul Kedrosky talking about AI’s future with New York Times journalist Ezra Klein: “.. one of the things that we don’t really talk about much is that a huge data center might employ very, very few people, indeed. I mean, it may be billions of dollars, but it’s a handful of jobs, and that’s not really – which is crazy — two to six people for a multibillion-dollar facility.”

Data center in New Carlisle, Indiana USA

All profit originates as surplus value but that doesn’t mean that the profit of Kedrosky’s hypothetical company comes from surplus value produced by the “two to six people” in his example. They would produce some but most of the profit would not come from their labor but from surplus value obtained on the market. In Marx theory, in the circulation process (the buying and selling of the commodities) no value is created but it is redistributed and the technologically advanced and/or monopolist capitals are rewarded with surplus value produced elsewhere. v

The inevitable result of capitalism’s moving contradiction is that the component of the production process which generates the growth of value is the shrinking part of the value producing machine. The commodities are made with less living labor and thus become cheaper. But the surplus value, the source of all capitalist wealth, can only come from living labor. It’s true that the relative decline of the value of wages (because the labor time needed for their equivalent declines) and the intensifying of work mean that the capitalist gets more surplus value out of a work day but there’s a limit:“its barrier always remains the relation between the fractional part of the day which expresses necessary labor and the entire working day. It can only move within those boundaries.” vi Even if intenser exploitation increases the rate of surplus value, that surplus value can only be a part of the labor time of the living labor, so when the latter keeps shrinking, it must do so as well.

Rate and Mass of Profit

But a falling rate of profit doesn’t necessarily imply a falling mass of profit. Can the latter’s growth compensate the former’s decline? A larger volume of production does not increase the mass of profit by itself, since “the mass of profit on the individual product decreases proportionately to the increase in the number of products. The mass of profit remains the same, but is distributed differently over the total amount of commodities” vii. But if the total productive employment rises, the total mass of surplus value still grows, even while each capital uses proportionally less living labor. “Marx spoke of “this double-edged law of a decrease in the rate of profit and a simultaneous increase in the absolute mass of profit, arising from the same causes”viii because the same technological progress which reduces the use of labour-power in production relatively, also enlarges capitalism’s scale of production and thereby increases the absolute amount of labour-power in the production process. And when the total amount of labour-power in production grows, its unpaid portion (the surplus value and hence the profit) grows too. It’s therefore logical that the fall of the rate of profit goes together with a rise of the mass of profit, since they are different aspects of the same process.” ix

In past technological revolutions the expansion they made possible of the capitalist mode of production was plain to see. The exertions itself of the scale-enhancement mobilized more living labor despite the latter’s decline in proportion to constant capital, and provided the market expansion which the scale- enhancement demanded. Even the internet had this effect, making ‘globalization’ possible. But it’s hard to see how AI could play that role. Even though its leaders want to go to the moon and to Mars (and we hope they’ll stay there) it’s still a mystery how it could expand capitalist production further on earth.

AI raises the organic composition of capital, the dominance of past labor over living labor in the production process, higher than ever before. To use the example of Kedrosky quoted above, if an investment of 100 billion creates employment for six people, a trillion would have to be invested to employ 60 people. Obviously Kedrosky was exaggerating to make a point but the tendency is clear. To prevent the mass of profit from falling, Marx pointed out, “an ever larger quantity of capital is required to employ the same, let alone an increased amount of labour-power (…)If the variable capital forms just 1/6 of the total capital instead of the former 1/2, the total capital must be trebled to employ the same amount of labour-power. And if twice as much labour-power is to be employed, the total capital must increase six-fold” x This is not something AI will accomplish.

I wrote above that the total mass of surplus value still grows if total productive employment rises. The word productive is essential here. The accumulation of value is a cyclical process consisting of several phases of transformation of value of which the productive phase, in which the value of the means of production is transformed into commodities, is the most important one because only in that phase surplus value is added, which is the ultimate source of all profit. But that doesn’t mean that capitalism needs only productive workers. A lot of unproductive work is needed for its system to function. And now that the inherent contradictions exacerbate, it spends ever more on ‘security’ and other costs it must incur to maintain its grip on society. Regarding some jobs, it may be open to discussion whether they contribute to the value of commodities or not, but for many, the unproductive nature of the work is quite obvious. Unproductive employment is a net-cost for total capital, not a source of profit. It may be reduced by the use of AI in the future, but for now it’s still a massive burden which hides the tendency of declining living labor in value production.

According to Marx’s theory, productivity-raising technology initially creates conditions which make fabulous profits possible for the fraction of capital that can cross the threshold and adopt the new technology quickly, but once the whole sector (or sectors) are using it, once it has become the norm, the fabulous profits melt, and the profit-rate, reflecting a lower average use of living labor, is lower than before, which pressures capitalists to escape from that downward trend by investing more in labor time-saving, productivity-raising technology. The cure worsens the sickness. “The rate of profit does not fall because labor becomes less productive, but because it becomes more productive”.xi

At the same time, the productivity-increase leads to overcapacity and the frantic search for new fields of profitable investment, for a new technology that will bring back fabulous profits. Meanwhile capitalism must borrow ever more from the future. But even an explosion of debt cannot do more than slow down the diminishing global return on capital investment. What is the perspective? What solution has capitalism given the world historically in such a situation other than war and depression? But now, here’s the AI boom. There is new hope, the stock market breaks records, the productivity bonanza of the “Superior Intelligence” (as emperor Trump has ordered us to call it) will make us all rich and happy.

Or not. The AI revolution, if that’s what it is, may be the ultimate test case on whether Marx’s analysis of how capitalism functions and malfunctions as a value system is right.

It may also become the moment at which the moving contradiction becomes too obvious to ignore. Marx emphasized the absurdity of the situation, pointing out that real wealth and capitalist wealth are two different things. The moving contradiction means that capital “on the one side, calls into life all the powers of science and of nature … in order to make the creation of wealth (relatively) independent of the labor time employed on it. On the other side, it wants to use labor time as the measuring rod for the giant forces thereby created”xii. The great well-spring of wealth, Marx observed already back then, is no longer labor time. It is knowledge, it is the general social intellect that creates the real wealth. In Marx’s view, measuring that real wealth with human labor time becomes crazy, and it becomes impossible to continue to do as the misalignment between real wealth and value wealth keeps growing. It shows capitalism is historically transient; it must end.

Sanderr

Next part: The Big Bet

iMarx, Grundrisse, p.704 (Penguin ed)

ii Beverley Best, author of The Automatic Fetish: The Law of Value in Marx’s Capital (Verso, 2024) explains this well: “Individual capitalists attempt to best their competitors largely by reducing their production costs relative to their competitors (which is the same thing as saying, by increasing their productivity in relation to that of their competitors). If they succeed, they reap the profit-benefits of this new advantage until the time when its means are standardized across the field of competition. When this happens, this initial “early-adopter advantage” enjoyed by our capitalist, now comes to express a new social average; that is to say, the profit-advantage is nullified in becoming the new social average price-point of production. The greater profits achieved by the out-performing capitalist are therefore ultimately temporary.”

iii There is no purely objective definition of the value of labor power. There is a social implicit recognition of what it is, so to some extent it is subjective; morality impacts it, and of course the tradition (or lack thereof) of class struggle. Furthermore, the value of labor power obviously is different in economies with different levels of development and is modified by levels of formation (more labor time is needed to produce skilled workers than unskilled workers).

iv Marx, Grundrisse. p. 340

v In Marx’s view, assuming a closed capitalist system, all surplus value =unpaid socially necessary labor time (SNLT) and the total profit=total surplus value . So if the capitalist with the higher labor productivity produces no more surplus value but gets a higher profit, what is the source of his surplus-profit? For Marx, by definition, no value is created outside the production process. No surplus value originates in the phase of circulation, in which the commodities resulting from production are bought and sold, to be unproductively consumed or employed as new productive forces. But while in this circulation no surplus value is created, it is redistributed. The market rewards the capitalist who pushes the value of a commodity under the social norm. But it rewards it with value that comes from elsewhere, be it from competitors who are forced to accept less than the SNLT that went into their own production, or from buyers who obtain less value in exchange.” (Sander, A Crisis of Value, IP 51, Fall 2009)

vi Marx, Grundrisse, p.340

vii Marx, Capital vol.3, p.229 ((New World Paperbacks edition)

viii Idem, p.220

ix Sander, The Fall Of The Rate Of Profit And The Rise Of The Mass Of Profit In The roots of capitalist crisis, Part One: The inevitable fall in the rate of profit. (Internationalist Perspective 30-31, p.14) 1996

x Marx, Capital, Vol 3, op.cit, p.223

xi Marx, Capital, Vol 3, p.240

xii Marx, Grundrisse, p.706

Subscribe to our newsletter below to get new articles delivered to your Inbox

Leave a Reply